When You've Gotta Go,
You've Gotta Go
by Jennie Borodko Stack
When you've gotta go, you've gotta go. But if you're away from home for business
or pleasure, many people with neuromuscular diseases say, you could also be out
of luck when nature calls.
From cupboard-sized airplane restrooms to inaccessible public facilities to
challenges involved in transferring independently, active people who have
limited mobility face numerous obstacles in emptying their bladders away from
| The Feminal (above) from A-Plus Medical is a portable urinal for women. The SpillProof URSEC male urinal is from Mobility Transfer Systems.
In some cases, the issue is accessibility. Not all public bathrooms labeled
"handicapped" are easily reached by people using wheelchairs, such as those
located on a different floor in a building with no elevator. Or the stalls may
be too small for a chair or too snug for self-transfer. Maybe the bathroom or
stall doors are hung awkwardly, creating a barrier to a person in a wheelchair.
Then there are situations in which the bathroom is accessible, but it's
impossible to transfer without assistance from a co-worker or a total stranger,
neither of which is usually a desirable option.
As for airplane restrooms — don't get us started. Tiny and often inaccessible to
begin with, those facilities are usually viewed by people with physical
disabilities as more trouble than they're worth. And considering the
consequences, that's saying a lot.
Leaving home for a few hours or more typically requires tough choices and can
result in some unpleasant realities, from holding it in until it hurts to being
dropped by unskilled attendants during a transfer. Choosing greater involvement
in life also may require tradeoffs that limit independence in other ways, such
as asking for transfer assistance when you'd rather not. Other choices can be
embarrassing ("just wear adult diapers"); painful ("just use a catheter"); and
even unhealthy ("just say 'no' to water").
To help find practical solutions to this difficult problem, Quest interviewed
product suppliers, health care practitioners and several people with
neuromuscular diseases. There's probably no single solution that will work for
everyone, but we hope these ideas may prove useful, either as presented or when
adapted to individual situations.
Ask for the Help You Need
Occupational therapist Vicki Pollyea of Tampa, Fla., has Charcot-Marie-Tooth
disease, which has weakened her extremities and caused her to use a wheelchair.
She can transfer herself, but fatigues easily. Pollyea works as a writer and
speaker on a part-time, freelance basis. When she leaves home on errands or
personal matters, she frequently obtains needed restroom help from her husband.
"I don't hesitate to ask for assistance when I need it, but obviously I'd rather
do these things independently," she says. "If all else fails and I can't get
into the bathroom I will go and lock the door to stop anyone else from coming
in and then have my husband come in and help me transfer."
On those occasions when help isn't available, Pollyea says she makes other
choices. "I very often do lose a bit of privacy on some of these things, but
you have to decide which is the easiest. Sometimes it's an energy-saving thing:
There is a bathroom, but it would require going from your vehicle to your chair
and getting in there. Maybe using a [portable] urinal in the vehicle with a
blanket around the shoulders would save some energy."
Some people deal with the accessibility issue by choosing to wear special
clothing, such as pants with open sides or seams, kept closed with Velcro.
Corrections counselor Gail Ableman of Cheney, Wash., finds those unacceptable.
Ableman has Friedreich's ataxia, which affects her balance. She uses a
wheelchair and can stand briefly to transfer. At work, she helps place female
prisoners in a work-release program, and the nature of her position requires
that she convey a strong, professional image.
| The Freshette urine collection device from International Sani-Fem Company may help some women with limited mobility.
"I can't let them know [my limitations]. I'm always telling them, 'Don't make me
get out of this chair!' I think they wonder if I can," she chuckles.
To maintain an authoritative image, she chooses to wear regular work clothing,
which makes it more time-consuming and difficult to urinate. Ableman admits,
"I've had to sit and ache many, many times. I guess it might be a pride thing.
There are times where I think, 'I can't do this anymore,' but I don't want to
use special clothing." To minimize her need to urinate away from home, she
reduces caffeine and other fluid intake and uses the bathroom before leaving
the house "whether I have to or not."
She adds, "The best thing is just to preplan. If I have an early morning trip I
have to be real careful about my timing. Everybody at work knows that, because
I have to ride on the handicap bus, it takes me two hours and I'd better not
have to use the bathroom during that time. When I get to work everybody yells,
'Hi Gail, go pee!' It's not even sensitive anymore."
Strategies that work well for the semiambulatory may be of little use to those
with more extensive muscle involvement. While an internal catheter or adult
diapers aren't very satisfactory solutions, those are two of the most common
suggestions, notably from people who aren't using them.
Medical supply companies offer options that include a variation on an internal
catheter. It features the usual tubing attached to a plastic collection bag,
but the tip inserted into the urethra is prelubricated, which is said to be
easier to insert and more comfortable to wear.
However, many women with neuromuscular diseases say they prefer not to run the
risk of infection or experience the discomfort that often results. Also, since
self-catheterization requires a certain amount of flexibility and fine motor
skill, those with limited upper-body mobility may require assistance with the
Writer June Price of Milwaukee has spinal muscular atrophy and wears a corset
and brace. She needs assistance in toileting and is an advocate for greater
availability of trained attendants.
Price relates the story of an acquaintance with SMA type 3. "She had been
clamoring for assistance from an agency to help her in the bathroom and the
head nurse from the agency, instead of trying to find someone to help lift her
on and off the toilet, her response was just, 'Get a catheter.'"
Price continues, "That's not a solution any more than it would be for [an
able-bodied person] to wear Depends during the daytime if you didn't have a key
to the washroom."
A Man's World
"For a guy who's got sensation, it's probably the last place a guy would go,"
says Jerry Ferro of internal catheterization. With a master's degree in
rehabilitation counseling, Ferro runs a private counseling practice and leads a
general support group for the Orlando, Fla., MDA chapter.
Men, for obvious anatomical reasons, have a somewhat easier time of it than
women when the bladder needs to be emptied away from home.
| A male external catheter, like these from Rochester Medical, is fitted with a flexible condom that allows for continuous collection and added comfort.
Ferro has SMA and uses a power wheelchair; he also uses a more comfortable
urinary-collection device called an external or condom catheter.
"Men that I know who can't go to the bathroom themselves find that this is very
helpful," he says. External collectors are available through medical suppliers
and, unlike internal catheters, don't require a doctor's prescription. Says
Mike Lee of DS Medical, "Basically, they're a condom with a hole in the end of
it attached to a tube that runs to a leg bag concealed under the pants. It's
completely concealed, so you could theoretically go for a long period of time
before you drain the leg bag."
However, during extended periods away from a toilet, even a large leg bag can
fill up. If there's no acceptable place to empty the leg bag, a typical
solution would be to use a portable plastic urinal as a temporary receptacle.
But for those who don't have room to conceal the device, a little creativity
makes a big difference.
"In public, we don't use a standard urinal because it's so obvious. We've found
that with the Big Gulp-size cups [from convenience stores], you can pretty well
hide them and nobody knows what they're for," says Ferro. In a private place
such as a vehicle, he empties the leg bag into the cup, then leaves the cup
hidden until he can dispose of it in a bathroom.
Where to Find Urinary Devices
DS Medical — Internal and external catheters, for males and
females. Components such as catheter condoms, leg bags. (800) 633-1565; www.medshipdirect.com.
A-Plus Medical — The Feminal, a portable plastic urinal for women. (888)
International Sani-Fem Com-pany — The Freshette, a female urine-collection
device. (800) 542-5580; www.freshette.com.
New Angle Products — The Whizzy, a disposable paper trough. (773) 293-2655; www.whizzy4you.com.
R.D. Equipment — Electric Leg Bag Emptier, device for draining leg bags. (508)
Mobility Transfer Systems — SpillProof URSEC male urinal. (888) 854-4687; www.bed-mobility.com.
OnTheGo — OnTheGo, a soft plastic cup and tube. (727) 533-9184.
Rochester Medical — Internal and external catheters for men and women. Supplies
and components such as tubing, collection bags and condoms for catheters. (800)
A Female What?!
For women who've ruled out catheterization and absorption products, there are
two kinds of urinary devices that might help.
Those with some upper-body strength or who have trusted assistants might be able
to use female urinals modified from the more familiar styles used by men.
They're designed to fit feminine anatomy and can be sterilized and reused. Most
are priced under $15, and can be used with or without assistance, as long as
the user can be positioned at the edge of a chair, with the device held in
place as it fills.
"It's designed ergonomically so that when it is pressed up against the perineal
area it seals. As long they have minimal control they can use it," says Linda
Asta, inventor of the Feminal, a urinal designed for women. "It holds 1,000
cubic centimeters [about a quart] and it's also designed for women who have
limited hand mobility as well. We do have patients who are bedridden. They can
hold it themselves or a caregiver can hold it for them."
Another type of aid is collect-and-deflect items that either shunt urine
directly into the toilet or send it to a tube that empties into the commode or
a container. The abilities they require range from having a trusted assistant
help guide the device into position to being able to stand briefly.
For example, OnTheGo is a soft, reusable plastic cup connected to tubing. "If
you're able to hold onto it and fit it snugly against the body, it does create
a seal so that there is no spillage when one is urinating. You would simply
have to be able to sit on a chair and have the tube hanging over the chair,"
says Kathleen Farrell, inventor of OnTheGo.
For those who can stand, but who experience difficulty with the up-down movement
of sitting and rising, a disposable paper trough called a Whizzy might help.
Created by Janis Wagner, who is affected by muscular rheumatism, the sturdy,
nonflushable product is designed for urinating from a standing position. To use
it, women need to be able to hold the lightweight funnel in place and to stand
long enough to void. Users face the toilet in a standing position.
"I designed it specifically so that... if someone does not have grip strength,
she can literally just let it rest on her fingers. I made it so that you don't
have to move your legs at all. You can keep them in a natural position. There
is no bending of any sort that's necessary," says Wagner.
| The Electric Leg Bag Emptier from R.D. Equipment enables users to drain leg bags more conveniently. An electric switch uses the wheelchair battery.
Daily Living Devices
Many people with neuromuscular disease find it useful to combine medical
equipment with strategies and independent-living aids.
For those with some arm strength, a sling-type device can be positioned under
one leg, then used to lift it out of the way before placing a urinary
collector. Other adaptive tools include a pair of plastic-coated tongs or a
longer-handled reach extender to add range of motion for wiping.
To leave hands free to aid in transfer and keep clothing accessible, some use a
large set of clips connected by a cord similar to the ones used to keep a bag
of potato chips closed. One clip attaches to the top of the pants, while the
other fastens to the shirt.
Be Healthy, Don't Dehydrate
While dealing with the need to urinate away from home may require careful timing
of fluids and selection of foods, it's essential to make up for liquid loss as
soon as possible.
Going without fluids for eight or more hours a day is dangerous.
"Dehydration leads to dry mouth, cramps and physical discomfort because your
electrolyte balance gets thrown off. Then the kidneys aren't getting flushed,
so that the medications you are taking are not being flushed properly," says
Maura Del Bene, a registered nurse who's clinical administrator of the Division
of Neuromuscular Disease at Columbia University in New York.
"Women are at risk for urinary tract infections for holding their urine for a
very long period of time."
Other possible risks of dehydration extend to cancer of the bladder, which is
believed to arise from irritation of the bladder lining triggered by a buildup
of chemicals. In a recent study by Harvard University of nearly 48,000 men,
those who consumed 88 ounces of liquid per day had half the incidence of
bladder cancer of that reported by men who drank 40 ounces per day or less. The
conclusion was that drinking plenty of fluids may help prevent the disease by
diluting the urine, said the researchers.
It's recommended that average-sized adults (a 140-pound woman or 175-pound man)
consume eight to 12 8-ounce glasses of noncaffeinated liquid daily. Don't wait
until you feel thirsty; by then, dehydration has already begun. Healthy urine
output is about 30 ounces, or nearly a quart, a day.
Another way to tell if you're getting enough water is by checking the color of
the urine. Liquid intake is adequate when the urine is pale yellow in color,
but when the body is deprived of needed fluid, the output decreases and the
urine turns much darker.